BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


New Dave Sim Works: Glamourpuss and Judenhass

 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
 
matthew.
08:09 / 28.02.08
What does "Godwin" mean in this context?
 
 
ziparrow's Flex On K9 Crack
(prev. ziparrow kent haz wiipuns?)
09:09 / 28.02.08
wiki article.
 
 
Our Lady Drinks Your Milkshake
10:51 / 28.02.08
The sixtieth anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz in 2005 made me think that every creative person should consider doing a work addressing the Shoah... at some point in his or her life.

1) I'm looking forward to the Roger Hargreaves version.

2) Hang on. Sim has opened up the possibility that a woman can be a creative person rather than a giant sucking leech on the male body. Is he going soft on his rampant misogyny?

It's not like Sim is the first person to draw a link between the Third Reich in Europe and comics creators like Siegel and Shuster creating superheroes that could give Hitler the punch on the chin they couldn't do.
 
 
H3ct0r L1m4
17:07 / 28.02.08
Heidi MacBeat wonders in a very long but worth reading post if you can set apart the brilliant work from the bigot artist.
 
 
grant
21:23 / 28.02.08
his next book was going to be called Bernie the Happy Red Aeroplane,

Well, nearly but he probably had some licensing problems.

By the end of that article, I'm left supposing it's a bit like collecting art from serial killers. The same mechanism at work. Not that I'm comparing Sim to Hitler or Gacy (those lovely clowns!), but there's something there.
 
 
Stoatie's power level is >9000
22:41 / 28.02.08
I don't think, Stoatie, that redemption is being sought.

Yeah, I know, but hope springs eternal. Look, if anyone's running a book, I'll put money on this being more misogynist mentalism. But if we couldn't have hope that the unlikeliest things may occasionally happen, the National Lottery would be fucked.

OK, I lied when I said I'd probably buy it. I'll most likely read it in a shop, or online. That way I get to piss off Dave Sim AND John Byrne. All free of charge.
 
 
Stoatie's power level is >9000
22:47 / 28.02.08
Not that I'm comparing Sim to Hitler or Gacy (those lovely clowns!), but there's something there.

Hey, at least Gacy got out of the house occasionally.
 
 
Jack Fear
00:08 / 29.02.08
That's exactly the thing, Stoat, that I find so weird about this project. Sim has just come off of, essentially, a thirty-year contemplation of his own navel—a 6,000 page experiment in spiritual autobiography and philosophy—and is just now starting to notice that there's a world beyond the confines of his own head and his comics collection.

And now, after years of being profoundly and aggressively disengaged from the larger world except inasmuch as it occasionally intersected with his own narrow and eccentric field of interests, he's taken it upon himself to explain history's greatest evil to us all.

The hubris and the arrogance of it are monumental. But what makes the enterprise irresistible is Sim's loopy, naïve sincerity. He's so earnest about this—he's like a college freshman who's just read Howard Zinn and holy shit his mind is blown. It's almost poignant, in a nostalgic sort of way—because we all have that period when we recognize the weight of history on our shoulders, and our place in the continuum, and we realize some larger truths about the world—and yeah, it is kind of mind-blowing.

But coming from a 52-year old man, it makes me want to throw up my hands and yell, "You're just figuring this out now?"
 
 
velvetvandal FTW!
(prev. velvetvandal)
00:25 / 29.02.08
The Third Reich versus the Fourth World!

Am I alone in thinking this would be a much better comic than Dave Sim vs the Holocaust?
 
 
Captain Zoom
02:34 / 29.02.08
*quietly, but desperately, tries to reseal can of worms and slink back to lurkerdom*
 
 
matthew.
04:06 / 29.02.08
Heidi MacBeat wonders in a very long but worth reading post if you can set apart the brilliant work from the bigot artist.

This is sort of what I was trying to say.
 
 
Sailor Warrior of Love&Justice
(prev. Damn, it's Pacific State again)
22:31 / 05.03.08
The first issue of Glamourpuss is really fucking boring.
 
 
Mark Parsons
23:59 / 05.03.08
*quietly, but desperately, tries to reseal can of worms and slink back to lurkerdom*

Zoom, for god's sake don't press that button!!

In all seriousness, Sim is a fascinating convo topic. Heidi's post is excellent.
 
 
Jrod
05:48 / 20.03.08
Sorry, but that preview for Judenhass is disgusting.

Haus already mentioned that Sim seems to think that the real horror of the Holocaust is that it might have claimed all his favorite comics writers and artists, but it's worth pointing out again. This is a man who will state, in all sincerity, that he could never hate Jews because they created the comics industry. It's not enough that they are human beings, oh no. It's all about what the Jews have done for him, Dave Sim, unappreciated genius. Why, had all those lovely Jews who created the first comics been killed, the world may have been denied Cerebus the Aardvark! I could puke.

His animated preview spends over half of its time listing every award Sim ever received. That would still be incredibly tacky if he was doing a comic about happy red airplanes, but he's making a comic about the fucking holocaust. Sim can't even reign in his bloated ego for five minutes and leave the spotlight his so-very-important story. He gives us a couple minutes to let the horror of Auschwitz sink in, then it's five minutes of "Hey, lookit me, I'm Dave Sim! Did you know I wrote the longest comic story of all time? As long as you don't count any Japanese comics, of course! Oh, oh, check out my awards! I sure am a great genius, ain't I?" It's sickening.

Sim doesn't leave much time in his preview outside of fluffing himself, but he does make a point of dismissing those who died in the concentration camps who weren't Jewish. See, the holocaust is a Jewish thing, so bringing up the gentiles who died is just bad form and probably antisemitism, oops, I mean Judenhass. I'm sure the fact that the others included leftists and homosexuals has nothing to do with it. Speaking of which, do you suppose he'll try to make a distinction between hating the other when that other is Jewish, and hating the other when that other is female, left-wing, or "extremist" Muslim (where extremist equals Arab or Persian, apparently)? If he does, the book might be worth buying. And when I say "buy," I mean "download from piratebay."
 
 
FinderWolf
05:50 / 21.03.08
is Glamorpuss actually out? I haven't seen it in stores anywhere...
 
 
Sailor Warrior of Love&Justice
(prev. Damn, it's Pacific State again)
15:40 / 21.03.08
Glamourpuss isn't out yet. Sim sent a few thousand copies to retailers.

You can find it naughty ways.

The most tedious thing you will ever read. Seriously.
 
  

Page: 1(2)

 
  
Add Your Reply