BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


D.C. Showcase Presents...

 
 
DavidXBrunt
12:12 / 21.01.06
They say genius' steal ideas wholesale so whoever came up with the idea for D.C.'s new Showcase range of books is clearly some kind of genius. Taking their cue from Marvels ever popular and rapidly expanding 'Essential' range these are phone book size, dirt cheap, black and white reprint collections.

I've bought the majority of the available books and I have to say that they're great value for money and great fun. The reproduction is for the most part perfectly acceptable and if you can get over the lack of colour you're in for a treat. D.C. should be congratulated for a couple of their changes to their graphic novel output in recent months and this line deserves to be a success.

A tenner these days will get you what? Half a dozen modern comics if you're lucky. With these you get hours of reading and even those stories that have dated have taken on an innovent charm rather than become unreadably old fashioned. As you can tell I'm won over by these books. Anyone else got any comments?

For those interested - The first two in the range were released at a special price of £7 per book, which gets you 500 pages of Silver Age goodness. The first book 'Superman' reprints his adventures from the dawn of the Silver Age (roughly 1958) and features the first appearances of Braniac, Kandor City, and Supergirl, as well as tussles with Lex Luthor and other notable foes. The second book 'Green Lantern' has Hal Jordans origin story and introduces Sinestro, Hector Hammond, Star Saphire, and the Green Lantern Corps.

Other volumes released so far, at the regular price of £11 include the incredibly violent and rather gripping 'Jonah Hex', the fun, funny, and funky 'Metamorpho' which takes it's cues as much from contemporary T.V. as comics, 'Justice League of America', the very silly 'Green Arrow', with future volumes to star the 'Teen Titans', Lois Lane and Jimmy Olsen in 'The Superman Family', Len Weins influential 'House of Mystery' and, er, 'The Haunted Tank'.
 
 
Benny the Ball
18:27 / 21.01.06
I've been waiting for a bit of spare money to get some of these, that and a little nod from someone, anyone, to say that they are worthwhile. I love the Marvel 'Essentials' but have always been more of a DC fan (I have several silver age books - mini books and the like - from DC, and love their old old LSH stuff), and have found a few of the Marvel books have not just dated, but were awfully written so that there isn't even that sense of fun from dated books (the best example of this is the recent X-Factor release, which is painfully bad) - the X-Men books have been great though. I'm very tempted to get the JLA and the GL books of these, but your post has made me more interested in the Superman and Jonah Hex books now!
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
22:40 / 21.01.06
I love both the Eseentials and Showcases because I'm a READER of comics and not a collector or such. I buy a lot of them because I like to read them.

The biggest difference I see is that DC's art in the silver age lends itself more to black and white reproduction, and their books look a lot "cleaner" than Marvel's. Marvel has nearly reprinted all of their silver age hero books, and taking them in big chuncks, it's easy to see how Stan's style of plotting, combined with the romance backgrounds of many of his artists led themselves to the Marvel House style of storytelling. Some of their books are so fun I read them as close to one sitting as I can (like the Ditko Spider-Man stuff, the FF after issue 40, the Dr. Strange books).

DC, on the other hand, really show their SF fandom background, with stories based on a scientific fact that someone read plugged into a fairly standard story. Their "off brand" stuff is far more interesting and the SDhowcases have converted me to being a Jonah Hex fan after years of not giving a damn about the character. I even like Tony DeZungia's art after HATING his inks over John Buscema. Metamorpho is a fun read, but the others are ones I have to put down after a story or two because of the sameness. It's clear that they were formula based, and made for a casual audience, whereas Marvel was pushing for a devoted fanbase.

I see that they have an agressive release schedule planned, and I hope that the "House of Mystery" book sells well so that they can reprint all of those hard-to-find short horror stories that DC did so well in the 70's. They should also do like Marvel has done in that they release a volume that ties in to a current use of a character, like when Marvel put our Spider-Woman as she became a prominent story figure in Avengers and got her own mini-series. DC also has a lot of smaller series in the 70's that ran 8 to 15 issues that it woudl be nice to see in this format, and they could run some as backups, as they did with the "Outlaw" stuff in Jonah Hex.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
23:01 / 21.01.06
Benny, I can heartily recommend these collections. If in doubt go for the Superman or Green Arrow collection because they're £4 cheaper than the others. Jonah Hex starts off fantastically, the first hundred pages are excellent but after that they settle down to being merely very good for the time, though that's damning with faint praise.

And speaking of Jonah, they tied that release in with the first issue of his new book, and had an ad for that in the back. And the new series a whole mess of fun too.
 
 
Boboss
22:15 / 22.01.06
I've never read any Silver Age Green Arrow comics - what's so crazy about them?
 
 
Benny the Ball
22:31 / 22.01.06
Okay, I've ordered the Superman and Jonah Hex books, looking forward to them now. On the essentials front, The marvel two in one essentials looks great for fun stories, the thing teaming up with various people (like Man Thing) to fight various monsters/aliens etc - plus the Moon Knight looks good. I love the old silver age stories, and the 70's stories so much, they remind me of the old marvel re-prints in the UK that always had things like The Thing and Yancy Street boys and Sub Mariner and Green Lantern full of angst and drawn by Buscuma and Adams and the such.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
22:53 / 22.01.06
Boboss, and I apologise about replying to my own thread but there you go, the thing about Green Arrow that tickled me the most is that I've always thought of him as the serious politicised character of recent years so seeing him as a silver age character having fun, wacky adventures was a shock in itself.

But the thing that makes it so odd and so fun is that there is little in the line of supervillains just crooks with gimmicks. It's like the Spiderman or Flash live action shows. They are two of the few comic characters to have decent casts of villaisn (there are maybe half a dozen decent Rogues Galleries) but the cost limitations meant they tended to fight men in suits. It's like that in Green Arrow but with no need for a budget or reality. Weird and wacky schemes like the gang who use a lens to steal money...

They set up a magnifying lens across a street and wear masks. When they see security guards carrying loot they leap out and scare them into thinking there are giants. Whilst the guards panic the gangsters henchmen nick take the money and run away.

It's silver age sillyness writ large.
 
 
Boboss
23:30 / 22.01.06
I apologise about replying to my own thread but there you go

Don't be silly. I always reply (alot) to my own threads.
 
 
Boboss
23:34 / 22.01.06
I'm gonna go buy it.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
11:39 / 24.01.06
Not got much more to add other than I've read a whole lot more of the Seperman book and it's more fun that I could possibly have imagined. As well as a long line of gangsters in hats the villains roster includes Lex Luthor, Braniac, Mr. Mxyzptlk, Titano the super ape, Metallo, Bizarro, rogue Kryptonians and even Mum and Dad Kent!

Stories involve Superman saying such deathless lines as 'If only they knew the truth - That it's MY mouth! But in spite of my heavy heart I'm glad to bring joy to these boys!", and it contains the first Supergirl - the one created by magic and not from Krypton - and the first Power Girl (I didn't even know that there had been first one), and see Clark (SUPERMAN) Kent going undercover as a steeplejack, a fireman, and...er...Alfred E. Neuman!

It's just about the best £7 I've spent on comics in a very long time, perhaps since I spent £7 on the Titan reprints of Zenith Phase III.
 
 
Benny the Ball
00:27 / 26.01.06
Okay, got Superman, Green Lantern and Metamorph - got Jonah Hex coming. These are fantastic. Just simple, short and fun stories, so far removed from the rape happy grimness that permiates every comic book at the moment. It's like Shadowhawk never happened!
 
 
Solitaire Rose as Tom Servo
07:45 / 26.01.06
Sadly, I appreciate the Superman one, but I just don't like those stories. I am, however, falling madly in love with the Jonah Hex book, and having never liked the character before, it's been an eye opener. The Green Lantern one was a disappointment because I already had all of the stories in the Archives, and I can't read them stright through. One at a time, they are fun, though.
 
 
doctorbeck
10:27 / 26.01.06
only got Superman so far and it's brilliant fun, snappy and storytelling alive with the possibilities of the medium, they look like that are having fun

was really struck by how badly clark / supes treats Louis Lane and how much fun they had with the ridiculousness of no one guessing that supes was clark
 
 
Benny the Ball
11:26 / 26.01.06
Yeah, I love all the 'phew, I'm so glad she didn't say yes to my fake proposal of marriage to put her off the sent that I'm really Superman' stuff. Carol Ferris is even worse in the GL stuff! I can't wait for Jonah Hex now, and may pick up a couple more when I'm in town today.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
15:49 / 26.02.07
There's now a vertable raft of these excellent publications to empty your money and eat your free time. I'm currently working through 5 books at once, reading a story at a time.

Challengers of the Unknown is the greatest Irwin Allen series never made. 4 brave men living on borrowed time live to challenge...the unknown. Free from the super hero form these are tales of uncanny monsters, strange aliens, and mysterious beards and all the more fun for the lack of nefarious capes.

The Phantom Stranger (incorporating Doctor 13) is another example of genre tweaking with the emphasis here on the uncanny. Doctor 13 is a pipe-smoking one man Scooby Gang foiling paranormal shysters and the Phantom...well...he's a spooky kooky sort with a self acknowledged air of mystery. It's a miracle he's not started a sentence "Whoooooo! I'm enigmatic I am! Whooooo!" so far.

Brave and the Bold Team Ups will be familiar to most. Reprinted by Titan, and more recently Panini Batman meets a whole host of characters who need sales boosting publicity for their flagging titles. Thrill to the Metal Men! Metamorpho! Dead Man! This contains one of my favourite characters Bork.

Aquaman - silly sixties nonsense with a salty aftertaste this isn't going to win him anymore fans but if you want to see what he was up to before he became all adolescently broody here's your chance.

Shazam! is a frustrating one. The covers reprinted mention that the issues initially contained archive reprints but this volume is purely the newly originated material. That said it's Denny O'Neil and Elliot Maggin - two solid writers - and C.C.Beck - much under rated - and it's often very funny. The idea of Mister Mind having been sent to the Electric Chair has had me chucking innapropriatley all day.

Upcoming releases that I, at least, am gagging for include The Flash, The Atom, further volumes of House of Mystery, Batman, Green Lantern, and Superman, as well as...and this has got me very excited indeed...The War That Time Forgot!
 
 
Grady Hendrix
21:36 / 30.05.07
So there's a whole slew of new DC Showcase stuff coming up and I find myself nursing a horse-sized nostalgia jones. I'm in the middle of putting together a film festival that is frying my brain and I need something smooth and fun to read once it ends in July that'll make me feel like I'm once more about 11 years old and hiding in my cousin's bedroom while the extended family kills and eats its young outside in the dining room, reading his stack of old comics. It's the closest I can come to returning to the womb, I guess. Pathetic.

Anyways, I picked up the SHAZAM showcase and loved it, and I'm a shoo-in to eventually pick up SUICIDE SQUAD and LEGION OF SUPERHEROES, but how do people feel about the rest of these? I'm looking for kooky, silver age nuttiness, but I still need that satisfaction of a decent story because I guess I'm just picky.

Some of the titles that tempt me: WAR THAT TIME FORGOT, BRAVE AND BOLD, ELONGATED MAN, THE ATOM, BATGIRL, UNKNOWN SOLDIER. But, are they any good?
 
 
Dcdnt Dytrppr n Lv
(prev. Decadent Daytripper in Love)
22:12 / 30.05.07
I know nothing of War That Time Forgot or much of The Unknown Soldier, but the rest of the books you listed should all worth their cover price. The Atom and Elongated Man were just better when they were happy and their SOs weren't dead or insane. And they were both kinda flirty for supertypes, which is always fun. Brave and the Bold is like the tour-book that couldn't be, because the continuity rarely connected to the rest of the DCU and just played things by audience recognition. I'm a bit biased on Batgirl, but you can see the good and the bad mulled over in the Scary Sex Stuff thread, right now.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
16:50 / 31.05.07
War that time forget gets old quickly, it's a fun read but each issue is, essentially, the same story with different characters.
 
 
Cowboy Scientist
05:39 / 01.06.07
That is a valid point; but in its defense i will say this:

Showcase presents: The War that Time Forgot contains this panel of a man doing a backflip while shooting a dinosaur with a machine gun while on skis:



'Nuff Said.
 
 
Boboss
11:09 / 01.06.07
That's amazing.
 
 
Grady Hendrix
14:29 / 01.06.07
"Gee!!" That's what Streaky the Super-cat says when Saturn Girl informs him that he, Super-Monkey, Krypto, and Supergirl's future Super-Horse are now the Legion of Super-pets. "Gee!!"

"DC Showcase presents: The Legion of Super-Heroes" is the closest reading has come to a sexual experience for me. If the Levitz/Giffen years were the Legion as "90210" ("Footballers' Wives" for you Brits), and if Giffen's "5 Years Later" was the Legion as "Lost" then these early-day Legion are what Waid and Kitson have returned to: the Legion as completely deranged After School Special.

In the "Showcase presents: Shazam!" the stories consist of Captain Marvel flying around and using his powers to do nice things or solve crimes. The Legion stories I've read so far consist of the Legion flying around and being dicks. Just like real teenagers! Sometimes it's revealed that they're really aliens in warm winter coats and disguise projectors pretending to be the Legion and sometimes it's revealed that they're being mind controlled, but tell that to Night Girl ("Because I loved and trusted Cosmic Boy, my comrade is DEAD!")

And there's a lot of mind control in these stories. I've only read three of them and already there's been enough mental manipulation, hypnosis and telepathic domination to fill a dozen erotic fantasy websites. But no one seems to mind much. When it's revealed that aliens (aliens who are giant brains in glass globes descended from humanoid ancestors who were so embarrassed by their skulls that look like warty, hairy penises that they preferred to survive as disembodied brains) have caused Superboy to try to kill all the passengers on an airplane, then have caused the Legion to try to kill Superboy and then have knocked the Earth out of its orbit, no one's really that upset. Their sense of self has been compromised, they have been mentally violated, turned into murderers, and had their free will erased as if it never existed in the first place. If Brian Michael Bendis was writing this it would be a 12 issue arc that ends with Lightning Lad traveling to the Marvel Universe so he could get Luke Cage to treat him to a night of rough sex. Here, the Legion just shrugs it off.

When an understandably dazed and shaky Superboy asks what happened, Saturn Girl smilingly informs him, "Sorry. I can't tell you...yet." Then thinks to herself, "Otherwise Superboy will learn about Super-Horse being Supergirl's pet." Sorry, Superboy, but we can't let you know why your mind just got completely cleaned out or you might learn that your cousin will one day own a pony. Man, does the human race evolve into jerks or what?

The aliens encountered by the Legion are inevitably weaker, uglier and far more fragile than the robust, attractive humanoids who make up the Legion. In fact, they never seem to run into opponents who are that much stronger than themselves unless they are a) dinosaurs, or b) robots. And the aliens are horrifying to look at, like hideous warts have mated with insects and their offspring fill the cosmos.

My only wish is that by the time I finish Volume 1, Volume 2 will be out.
 
 
Secret Bat-Fairies
(prev. Smith & Papers)
18:07 / 01.06.07
Plus there was the early stories where they were still tweaking the concept - the Legion coming back to the twentieth century to visit Supergirl and, er, claiming to be their own children. Who grew up to look identical to their parents. And use the same codenames. Yeah, there isn't any possible way that isn't a prank. One of the early Legion by-laws was that members had to travel in time once a year to pull some ridiculous prank on a member of the Superman Family...toying with Jimmy Olsen's fanboy heart, for example.

And sometimes they were being jerks in the name of protecting each other! Saturn Girl making herself leader and then kicking out and psychologically torturing every single member of the Legion so that she's the only one left to potentially die in some random accident.
 
 
MattShepherd: LARGELY ABSENT!
18:28 / 01.06.07
Just ordered LSH and Metamorpho. I kept looking at the HoM ones, but they're just too hit-and-miss for me.
 
 
Secret Bat-Fairies
(prev. Smith & Papers)
18:40 / 01.06.07
Metamorpho...I keep meaning to pick it up. Anyone have a firm opinion on its merits?

Also, they've got to put out the Metal Men soon, and the Doom Patrol stuff...
 
 
Elijah, Freelance Rabbi
21:58 / 05.06.07
There is already a hardcover(?) collection of early DP stuff I think. Are they re re printing things in the showcase format?
 
 
Secret Bat-Fairies
(prev. Smith & Papers)
00:03 / 06.06.07
The hardcover stuff is the tres expensive Archives format, innit? From what I understood, the Showcase books were supposed to be low-rent, lower-quality paper cheap-easy versions, and consequently there would be some overlapping titles.
 
 
DavidXBrunt
11:10 / 06.06.07
There already is some crossover between the Archives and the Showcases, so there's no reason why Doom Patrol shouldn't be released. The fact that some issues are easily available for the repro bods makes them less work. I'm certain I've read that in that case it's just a matter of time.

As for Metamorpho, it's great fun. It seems as much influenced by the telly of the time as anything else. It's funny, it's funky, it's well drawn, and it's got memorable charactrs. One thing in it's favour is it's supporting cast. When a book dies it's usually only the stars that carry on having any role in the wider D.C.U. but Java, Stagg, and Saphire have all been remembered. The cover is very obviously chosen to appeal to Sandman readers, and if they enjoy it that's great. Ultimatley this series deserves it's early reprinting as much as Jonah Hex.

I read it on a terrible night. My girlfs sister was rushed to hospital and all I could do was wait for updates by phone. I needed distracting and none of my favourite distractions (Doctor Who, Seinfeld, 2000 A.D., Emma - best novel ever!) could help. This helped enormously. Wonderful stuff.
 
  
Add Your Reply