BARBELITH underground
 

Subcultural engagement for the 21st Century...
Barbelith is a new kind of community (find out more)...
You can login or register.


Orange Prize 2005

 
 
Ariadne
14:40 / 08.06.05
Who's read any of the shortlist?

I've just bought the winner, Lionel Shriver's We Need to Talk About Kevin, and A Short History of Tractors in Ukrainian by Marina Lewycka.

I started the Shriver one in the park at lunchtime and got hooked - it was hard to come back to work and I'm looking forward to reading it. As someone who has never wanted children, it's fairly affirming, after even a few pages! But that's not the reason I like it - it has a lovely structure and tone so far, and I hope that'll continue.

The shortlist also included:

Billie Morgan by Joolz Denby
Old Filth by Jane Gardam
The Mammoth Cheese by Sheri Holman
and Liars and Saints by Maile Meloy

Anyone read them?
 
 
Stoat-ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWAH
17:12 / 08.06.05
I've read the Joolz Denby one (surprise surprise)- it's excellent, if a little grim (again, surprise!) There's a great passage in it about "the tyranny of the weak" or some such which I've been meaning to dig out for the Commonplace thread.
 
 
Cat Chant
14:46 / 13.06.05
I've read We Need To Talk About Kevin, and it's one of the twenty or so worst books I have ever read. It's sort of like Ruth Rendell, in that it's a "psychological thriller" with completely implausible psychology and a completely incompetent handling of the thriller genre. I was genuinely amazed when it was shortlisted and I still can't believe it won. But probably there should be a separate thread on it.
 
 
Stoat-ROW ROW FIGHT THE POWAH
15:11 / 13.06.05
Deva: oh bugger... I have a copy and it's next on my "to read" list. Oh well. Maybe I'll love it and we can argue about it later.
 
 
The Strobe
15:35 / 13.06.05
I've skimmed some of the Shriver; it didn't seem great shakes, but maybe it deserves a fuller reading.
 
 
Ariadne
14:27 / 14.06.05
Wow, I'm interested that you disliked it that much, Deva. I really enjoyed it – and didn't see it as a 'thriller' at all, given that most of the events were made clear right from the beginning.

Okay, I can't write about this without talking about what happens, so ...

S
P
O
I
L
E
R
S

My first reaction to it was one of intense identification – I don't want children and the beginning of it, where she described her decision about whether to have one, and her reactions to pregnancy ... well, to be honest I over-identified at first, and was just looking to the book to confirm my own feelings!

As Kevin grew up and appeared to be the devil-incarnate, there was that shift back and forward – is he actually disturbed, or is it due to her reactions to her – what's the cause and effect? I'm aware that I'm reading it as a relatively selfish, un-maternal person and so I imagine my sympathy for Eva goes much further than other people's would.

Anyway, without going through the novel blow by blow, I thought it was well done – the drama, the relationship between Eva and her husband, Eva and Kevin, the family tensions and incomprehension. And yes, there was a bit of a twist – and not an entirely shocking one – at the end, but I thought that fitted well enough – it had been becoming more obvious that something was amiss with Franklyn.

So, yes, I'd recommend it, and be interested to see what other people think.
 
 
Cat Chant
16:03 / 14.06.05
Ariadne - I'm interested in talking about this (I love when people can explain why they like books I hate) but have put it in a new thread so as to be able to talk about it in more detail w/o committing spoilers in this thread...
 
  
Add Your Reply