| |
|
At the moment, the arguments against moving it to Convo are:
1) For reasons that remain opaque, Paranoidwriter does not want it moved. Certainly, he has contributed a large amount of text to this thread, and perhaps as such we should recognise his investment in its future.
2) If we move it, John the Exploding Boy will take the opportunity to tell us all about Political Correctness Gone Mad.
3) The Conversation has done nothing to deserve this.
After four solid pages of threadrot, I think the case for locking it and letting it sink is probably stronger than the case for moving it. However, I'm open to discussion. So far PW wants it to stay here, Nina, Monk and Stoat seem to think that some variation of moving it to the Conversation would be appropriate. Monk also thinks it should be locked, with unlocking to be discussed at a later point. Nina thinks this may also work. Bed Head has suggested something similar - that it be left to sink and _then_ moved to the Conversation, although ignominious has pointed out that if it is unlocked it can (and probably will, realistically, as it is such a heck of a search term) be bumped to the top of the lists very quickly. Alex has proposed it be locked. So far, the only person who is for keeping it in the Policy and unlocked is Paranoidwriter, and presumably the moderator who voted against the move - whose input would be welcome. I hadn't realised that moderators were mere conduits for the will of the people, but at the moment, since the will of the people is to moderate this thread, if we _are_ then we are not doing a very good job of it.
toksik, Nina, Alex, Monk and I have all asked PW to explain why he wants the thread to remain unlocked and in Polcy, so far without success. |
|
|
